Theoderic

Thanks for the heads up - I will check out Coryssa for them. Thanks TIF. I would like to get them in an easily printed form so I can keep them with the catalogs for future reference but good to know the info is there too.

I recently finishing acquiring all 10 sale catalogs of the BCD collection of Greek coins. However, several of the older ones do not have their Prices Realized lists included. Although these usually can be found online these firms are no longer active and I haven't located them elsewhere. Does anyone know where copies or PDFs of these can be found? Lanz 105 - Nov 26, 2001 Lanz 111 - Nov 25, 2002 Leu 90 - May 10, 2004 Muenzen & Medaillen 23 - Oct 18, 2007

I think Andrew's reasons for pursuing coins with provenance were very clearly stated. As we collectors face an ever changing landscape of legal restrictions on our hobby it is sensible and prudent to minimize risk for ourselves and heirs by seeking coins that avoid these issues as much as possible. This is to say nothing of the joy and satisfaction in being the current caretaker of a coin that's known chain of ownership may stretch back a century or more. As for those who could find provenance of Roman Republican coins I doubt there are 10 people on this planet who have the knowledge, resources and time of Andrew.

Indeed. After their legal troubles broke, all mention of the Mare Nostrum provenance disappeared from subsequent auctions that included many similar looking western solidi. After winning one attributed to Odovacar last November I inquired with them if it was from that hoard. They said it was not and confirmed that there were no longer plans to publish the hoard. AV Solidus (20 mm, 4.28 grams, 6h), Struck in the name of Zeno, A.D. 476-491, Rome mint Obverse: D N ZENO P-ERP F AVG, pearl-diademed, helmeted, and cuirassed bust facing slightly right, holding spear over right shoulder, shield on left arm decorated with horseman riding down an enemy soldier Reverse: VICTORI-A AVGGG R, Victory standing left, holding long jeweled cross in right hand; star in right field; COMOB in exergue References: RIC X 3653; Depeyrot 88/2; DOCLR 686 Auction: Roma XXIX (November 9, 2023), lot 605

Handsome coins from everyone. It's a shame we don't have more historical accounts from this lengthy peaceful reign but no doubt the Romans who were fortunate enough to live during this era were agreeable to the trade-off. AE As (28 mm, 11.01 grams, 6h), Struck A.D. 147, Rome mint Obverse: ANTONINVS AVG PIVS P P TR P COS IIII, laureate head right Reverse: S P Q R / OPTIMO / PRINCIPI / S C within a laurel wreath with ties below and a medallion joint at ends References: RIC III 827a; BMCRE IV 1762 Auction: Nomos 24 (May 22, 2022), lot 409

The most hurtful loss and "open wound" in my collection is an aureus of Matidia that I won at Oslo Myntgalleri's Auction 28 in May 2022. A rarity in any condition, it had an impressive provenance of 100+ years and in my opinion was an absolutely beauty. I also think I got it at a great price! What could go wrong? Well, on its way to me from Norway it disappeared after arriving at the Fedex hub in Memphis TN. The folks at Oslo Myntgalleri were very cooperative and did their best to follow up with Fedex to investigate and track it down. However, it was all for naught and after a couple months of fruitless searching I was refunded the money for the purchase. Although I didn't lose a dollar, I was heart-broken at the loss. The only aureus I own is a Forum issue of Trajan and I viewed this coin of his favorite niece as an appropriate companion that would have been the centerpiece of my collection. I always wonder where it is now. Matidia, Augusta, AD 112-119, AV aureus, 7.01 grams, struck under Trajan AD 112-117, Rome mint Obverse: MATIDIA AVG DIVAE MARCIANAE F, Draped bust of Matidia right, wearing stephane Reverse: PIETAS AVGVST, Matidia as Pietas, standing facing with head to left, placing hands on the heads of Sabina and Matidia the Younger Reference: RIC II 759 (Trajan); Calico 1157a Provenance: NAC 34 (24-Nov-2006) lot 158; Aufhaeuser 17 (2003) lot 293; M&M XIX (1959) lot 211; Egger XXXIX (1912) lot 911

Anytime I see the word dodecahedron (and how seldom is that?) I always think of the old Simpsons episode where Lisa is trying to teach little sister Maggie her first word:

What about Georges Depeyrot's "Le Numeraire Merovingien L'Age de L'Or" published in 1998? It's only 199 pages with 8 plates (black & white, not color) but it seems to be the most recent overview and is usually cited in auction listings alongside Prou and Belfort. I can't read a word of French though, so I never bought it or any of the additional 4 volumes covering the silver deniers. If any of our French readers have an opinion on Depeyrot's work I would appreciate their comments. Perhaps it is worth slogging through it with Google Translate?

I would say the first with its uniform patina and problem free surfaces. Regarding the second one, I haven't had much experience in treating BD but I understand from others who've posted on how to do it that the treatment may affect the patina. I also wonder if someone has already polished or rubbed areas of the second piece - it seems too perfect that the smoke clouds contrast so well with the surrounding areas.

Thanks for posting this Donna. I used to work in Manhattan and would regularly bring my daughter in to see exhibits of interest at the Met - the magnificent re-opening of the Greco-Roman galleries in 2007 being a particular highlight - but I rarely have opportunity or desire to head into the city these days so I appreciate this review of a new show that I wasn't aware of. I just might have to drag that daughter of mine on to the train to see this. I especially like the reverse photo of the medallion and coin pectoral because I've been seeing only the front of that piece in their display case for years!

It was the Rowdy Roddy Piper line from the cult classic movie "They Live" that brought me here; it was the coins of Julian that made me stay. Here is my one coin of his: AE1 (29 mm, 9.78 grams, 6h), Sirmium mint (Sremska Mitrovica, Serbia), 2nd officina Obverse: D N FL CL IVLI-ANVS P F AVG, diademed, draped, and cuirassed bust right Reverse: SECURITAS REI PVB, bull standing right, two stars above; BSIRM (wreath) in exergue Reference: RIC VIII 105 Auction: Elsen 64 (December 2, 2002), lot 636

Edessa, thank you so much - I really appreciate it. Comparing both sets of images I think they may indeed be a die match but difficult to tell since mine's not in as good as condition. Besides the example from the British Museum, which is from different dies, I haven't been able to find online photos of any other RIC 1 aureus.

If anyone has a copy of Calico's "The Roman Aurei" and could post a screenshot of the entry and image for 2449 I would be most grateful. I recently won this holed but rather rare aureus of Septimius Severus that supposedly is a die match to the example cited in Calico so I'd like to double-check it. RIC 1 (denarius), BMC 5. Thank you!

Congrats on this aureus acquisition as I was one of the unsuccessful bidders on it. I did just win the similarly holed Septimius Severus aureus from their auction last week but haven't received it yet. I'm intrigued by the double piercing which is somewhat typical of Roman aurei found in India. If one could only know the story of these well travelled coins!

Yes! We constantly hear in these collectors' forums how coins of Gordian III are so common even in excellent condition that they are almost worthless. I am a picky (= condition snob) collector and I'm afraid that this mindset has virtually paralyzed me in pulling the trigger on a Gordian III purchase. I've seen so many beautiful examples at auction but if it has even the slightest imperfection, real or imagined, I think to myself "I'll pass on this one; I can 'always' find better". Well I've been collecting Roman Imperials since 1994 but I still don't have a single Gordian III in my collection. As Hans and Franz said, "Hear me now; believe me later!" - if you see a Gordian III that speaks to you just get it!