Ed Snible

Get well soon! Uncertain artist. 1955, Bronze, 58mm. Circa 83-87 g. Obv: Bacterium Streptomyces Rimosus Rev: CLIN-BYLA / PFIZER / S.I.B. / MASSY S.I.B. is Société industrielle de biochimie. Clin Byla was a French company that merged and took on a new name in 1980. Pfizer is a US pharmaceutical company. Massy is a commune (municipality) in France. See https://pharmainnumis.fr/index.php/produit/clin-byla-pfizer/ which illustrates a variant dated June 1955.

Scanning is fairly cheap. Many catalogs have already been scanned but can't be shared. The expensive part is getting legal clearance from defunct entities. Even Google was unable to do this. We haven't yet had legal precedent about the copyright status of a Large Language Model trained from copyrighted text. If any countries get a legal precedent that allows web sites to use data derived from copyrighted works we should the kinds of tools @Prieure de Sion desires soon after. It is worth pointing out that provenance finding tools will be great fun for collectors, but might take away the fun of people who have built large reference libraries and are doing the research today. It's also worth pointing out that although people collect catalogs, I don't know of anyone collecting the intellectual property behind the catalogs. For example, I have dozens of old Alex G Malloy catalogs. Each has photos and descriptions of thousands of coins. I have used them to track down provenance. In theory, any of us could write Mr. Malloy and offer him a small amount of cash in exchange for the copyrights on the catalogs he put out for 27 years. I think we are all fools, myself included, to ignore collecting the copyrights.

@Prieure de Sion the only person in the world who can search in the way you suggest is Dr. Jonas Emmanuel Flueck. He scanned a large library of catalogs and hired a programmer. The only way I have found pre-1999 provenances is through the ANS library. To do this I first memorized my collection. On every visit to the ANS library I pull down the boxes of catalogs from a particular dealer and flip through all of the plates. It's time consuming! I've gone through the big dealers but still have many more dealers to go. Without a library, you are limited to flipping through the catalogs of dealers that appear on the sites I gave, which is mostly Harlan Berk, CNG, and NFA. I enjoy this kind of thing, but many collectors do not. Spring's book on auction catalogs stopped in 1985 because they number of catalogs was starting to explode. Copyright law is 95 years. I am sure in the 2081 AD time-frame there will be web sites that will let you search the way Dr. Fleuck does. By 2095 most catalogs will be searchable digitally. This is why provenance research is so expensive (see other thread!).

You can often find pre-1920 stuff at https://www.rnumis.com/frontpage.php , https://www.hathitrust.org/ , and https://books.google.com/ . For catalogs from the 1930s-1960s, you must purchase them. Try eBay, https://www.numislit.com/ and https://www.vcoins.com/en/stores/charles_davis-44/ancient-coins/Default.aspx . Before you start purchasing, probably buy John Spring, Ancient Coin Auction Catalogs and Dennis Kroh, Ancient Coin Reference Reviews. Scanning the books recommended by Spring is how https://www.ex-numis.com/ got started. For catalogs from the 1970s-1990s, these are unavailable at any price. You can sometimes get them for free, when your friends are getting ready to move to Florida. Some stuff might be on https://nnp.wustl.edu/ . You can visit the ANS library in New York City. Online, if you are interested in Roman Republican, there are the Schaefer notebooks.

This coin is a great mystery to me. It is from an old Triton group lot. Another example was in the Pozzi collection (3359ter). Other than those two, I've never seen another. I have no idea if the shield shows a Chi or a cross. Euboea, Chalkis (?), 1.28g, AE11 Obv: Female head wearing triangular earring right Rev: Cross or Χ (Chi) upon circular shield Pozzi 3359ter, otherwise perhaps unpublished CNG, Triton VI, January 2003, lot 1563 (part of) David Freedman collection. Described as 'Uncertain, possibly Selge'. Here is half a shield: BOIOTIA, Thebes. 525-480 BC. AR Hemiobol (0.53 g). Obv: Half Boiotian shield Ref: BMC p. 33, 13. Ex two "name" sales: - Classical Numismatic Group, Triton IX, January 2006, lot 326 (BCD collection) - Malter 49, 15 November 1992, lot 422 (Dr. J.S. Wilkinson Collection)

@Ryro you now need to find a specimen with the elephant walking left. Seleukid, Antiochos III. Fifth Syrian War (202-198 BC)?, 4.65g 17.3mm (Unofficial imitation of?) Uncertain mint, probably a military mint in Coele-Syria (the modern Beqaa Valley, Lebanon) Ref: Seleucid Coins — ; Nicholas L. Wright, "Two new imitative issues from the fifth Syrian war (202-198 BCE)", Israel Numismatic Research 2009, page 47, #1 ex-AncientImports.com, April 2008

Sogdian: Chach, Kanka domain, unknown ruler 7-8th century AD. 20mm 1.78g. The reverse features a tamga is surrounded by the Sogdian legend ZNH pny tkyn c'cynk xwb - “This is the coin of the Tegin, ruler of Chach”.

DALL·E wasn't given many ancient images to train on. It is surprising that it can generate ancient-looking art all. At least it tried. I have found the output more interesting when I ask for things that never existed. I asked for "An Ancient Greek Lincoln cent". It already looks better than the Sponsianus coin!

Several different government organizations make the rules. The ACCG is fighting the State Department over their Memorandums of Understanding. In the case of Iran, this rule doesn't come from the State Department, but from the Office of Foreign Asset Control, a department of the U.S. Treasury, and these guys are still enforcing the sanctions from the 1979 Hostage Crisis when Iranian college students seized the US embassy and held diplomats hostage for 444 days. A few years ago US Customs seized an antique vase from Iran. The Treasury is looking for goods from Cuba, Iran, Burma (Myanmar) and most of Sudan. According to US Customs you are allowed to import "books, magazines, films, posters, photographs, microfilms, tapes, CDs, records, works of art, etc. Also gifts of up to $100 (U.S.) in value." It is sort-of unclear if ancient coins are works of art. Coins also circulated widely, and it is unclear if a Persian coin minted on the territory of modern-day Iran but found in a medieval hoard buried outside of Iran is "Iranian". Best approach: Buy coins imported into the USA during or before the time of the Shah. Also OK: Become a lawyer, study the law, realize it is unclear, import some Persian coins minted in medieval Tehran as a test, fight US Customs for a decade or more establishing precedent.

It all depends on the questions you ask. I asked "Which Roman philosophers would have viewed the Byzantine Empire as a continuation of the Roman Empire?"

I don't know who is working on these. This 20-year-old article is the best summary of the coins of Olbia that I have found: A. M. Gilevich, “Coins from the Excavations on Berezan Island, 1962-1991”, Northern Pontiac Antiquities in the State Hermitage Museum (2001) For a long time I thought the "Parion" gorgon/incuse coins were from Olbia. I no longer believe that. The Olbia coinage itself remains mysterious.

@Monolith I have seen Olbia bronze duplicates. I don't know if the mold is re-used, or the same "mother" was used to create duplicate molds.

@ambr0zie I can't recall my password and only used it anonymously. Try visiting http://forgerynetwork.com/ in an "incognito" window to see if your problem is with old cookies. If it works in an incognito window there is something wrong with the cookies.

I sent Mark a message to let him know (via Facebook, as I lack his email). In the past the problem has been due to other servers, and he has fixed those problems quickly.

I had never seen one of these before. It looked cool. Later I found out I paid full retail. Augustus, AE quadrans. C. Naevius Capella, moneyer. Struck 4 BC. 14.5mm, 2.98g. Lugdunum mint. Obv: III VIR•A•A•A•F•F•; garlanded altar with bowl-shaped top Rev: C RVBELLIVS BLANDVS legend around large SC A similar design was used on a modern coin: Isle of Man 1991 50 Pence. (Using the image from Numista because I don't have a photo of my specimen).

If you like ancient poppies you might enjoy this 55-year-old article from the United Nations Office of Drugs and Crime: "The history of the poppy and of opium and their expansion in antiquity in the eastern Mediterranean area" by P. G. KRITIKOS and S. P. PAPADAKI. Part 2, the coin part, is here. Here is another coin. This one was tough to attribute for me. Moesia Inferior, Tomi. Nerva (96-98 AD), AE16, 2.91g; RPC vol. 3 #778 Obv: [ΑΥΤΟΚΡΑΤωΡ Ν]ΕΡΟΥΑ; laureate head of Nerva, r. Rev: [ΤΟ/Μ//ƐΙΤ/]ωΝ; bunch of 3 ears of corn and 2 poppy heads ex Pegasi Numismatics, WESPNEX coin show, 2005 (misattributed as an unpublished coin of Elaeia in Aeolis.)

Earlier issues show a clear gorgoneion with bulging eyes protruding tongue: PISIDIA. Selge? PAMPHYLIA, Aspendos? AR obol (14mm, 0.88 gm, 12h). At some point there was a change and gorgons supposedly start looking beautiful. Think of the side views of Medusa on coins of Seleukos I and of the Roman Republican moneyer Sabula. The coins of Selge and Aspendos seem to change over to a very Helios-looking face at some point. I is not obvious when it happens. When the tongue goes away? When the expression becomes mild? Where should the line be drawn? PISIDIA, Etenna? 0.99g 9mm O: Facing head (humanized gorgon?). R: "t" and astragalos behind helmeted head (of Athena?). Acquired from Atlantis Ltd (May 2003)

This coin looks double-struck, but actually the first strike was a brockage strike. Rome, Probus, Antoninianus. 4.22g, 22mm Ref: RIC V Probus 173

@maridvnvm I suspect your "Amisis" is a Scythian imitation. http://digitalhn.blogspot.com/2015/12/imitations-of-bronze-coinage-of-pontos.html L. Plautius Plancus. 47 B.C. AR denarius (18 mm, 3.62 g). Brockage strike. Rome. Obv: L · PLAV[TIV]S below, head of Medusa facing Rev: Incuse of obverse. Classical Numismatic Group, e-auction 59, February 2003, lot 131.

@DLTcoins If you join the ONS you may attend via Zoom and engage in the Q&A. https://www.orientalnumismaticsociety.org/sections/north-america/ In the spring I will upload a video to the ONS YouTube channel. Subscribe to be notified at https://www.youtube.com/@orientalnumismaticsociety5508/videos

If anyone wants to meet me, I will be hosting the Oriental Numismatic Society meeting at 4pm on Saturday. We have three interesting speakers lined up. John Deyell - A Uniface Indo-Sasanian Coin Reveals Ancient Minting Techniques (via Zoom) Pankaj Tandon - Analysis of the Metal Content in Gupta Gold Coins. Michael Bates - The Earliest Muslim Coinage of Iran.

In the early years one could walk in at noon and head directly to that table to find 25% of this fixed price list was already sold during dealer set up. Later, the Fixed Price coins showed up on the CNG website at midnight before the show. 10am seems a lot more civil.

Gallica is full of amazing books and coins! I haven't looked at the books. I have been looking at coins. Many coins in the amazing collection of the Museum of the Bibliothèque nationale de France are online, but without metadata to search for them. Here is a small (~2 g) silver coin, probably of archaic Macedonia. Female confronting bull. I don’t recall seeing another. The metadata merely gives the weight and the date range 620-294 BC. https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b8591441d I wish there was some kind of effort to categorize or link to the most important works and coins there.

The link is https://www.academia.edu/12323949/Coin_Collectors_and_Cultural_Property_Nationalism The paper is from 2010.

https://wgs.cc/celator/ says "Kerry published it for another 13 years before experiencing significant health problems and being forced to cease publishing of the journal in its 25th year."