This is a post I made on another board ca 2020. I suspect Caligula will not be your highest priced coin. That would be Julius Caesar, followed by Otho and Galba, depending upon denomination. Vitellius will be pricey as well. The others are much more accessible. I completed my set for $2387 over several years.
—-
Consummatum Est.
So about fifteen years after getting my first Twelve Caesars coin, I have finally finished my Twelve Caesars set to
my satisfaction. I say “to my satisfaction” because it was technically complete after I bought Orfew’s Otho in
AMCC 2. But my Titus was a slug, so I bought a better Titus a few weeks ago. It just came in today from the Great
White North. Here’s a “virtual tray.” A group photo is below.
I subscribe to the school that says there are no rules for a Twelve Caesars set. But my arbitrary guidelines were 1) all
imperial (no provincial); 2) all bronze. I soon found out that imperial bronze was impossible for Julius Caesar and
Otho, so I had to go denarii there. I also recognized that sestertii would be out of my price range. I’m happy with the
middle bronze (AE as) collection I assembled. My favorite might be humble Claudius, with its genuine and
attractive desert patina. My least favorite? Let’s face it. That Vitellius is a pretty ugly coin. But Vitellius in bronze is
precious regardless of condition.
For anyone who is interested, here’s a chart with the acquisition year, the seller, and the price. Perhaps it’s a bit crass
to list price, but I know that when I was thinking about making a serious run at a Twelve Caesars set, I was curious
what it could be done for. Still, I had no real budget or timeline. I just bought the next coin that I could afford at the
time. Predictably, the Julius Caesar denarius comes in at the most expensive, followed by the usual suspects Otho,
Galba, and Vitellius. That Year of the Four Emperors is hard on the ol’ budget! The Augustus Altar of Lugdunum
comes in at the cheapest. The Nero price is from 2005; that coin would probably cost me a lot more today.
I got serious about making a run at a Twelve Caesars set in 2017 (note that almost half of the set was bought in 2018
alone). I really didn’t think I would land a Julius Caesar portrait denarius until maybe as a retirement gift to myself
in the distant future. But a pleasing budget option happened to show up in VCoins just at a time when I had a little
extra money, so I figured that was the universe telling me to go for it. I’m glad I did.
It may be interesting that only two coins come from auction (one being an unsold lot). I’ve returned to serious
collecting only in the past three years or so and am still an auction neophyte; my VCoins purchases show me
hugging the shore.
In the future, I would like to upgrade my Caligula. (I actually have two and would probably sell both and invest in a
better grade.) I might also get provincial bronzes of Julius Caesar and Otho just to have an all-middle-bronze lineup.