Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Beyond ecstatic to finally have this ebay win in hand!

Zombodroid_09062023124829.jpg.0ba4e40001246e5785b75f595da4c642.jpg

At first glance, I had assumed this to be one of the first iterations of Track 1, which would eventually evolve into the Gadhaiya coinsZomboDroid22022022111423.jpg.160994f2db1e9d1e85fbbf0b8c0536a0.jpg

But on closer inspection, I noticed that the korymbos (orb or hair bun wrapped in gold foil) was not an orb at all as on all Series 1.1, but was in fact the late Brahmi / early Nagari letter SA, which automatically places it in Track 2, which all have SA above the headgear instead of a korymbos. This is particularly intriguing because the earliest known coins of Track 2 look like this

Zombodroid_23012023101946.jpg.782d78478962eb880af47ddce276cf4d.jpgZombodroid_23012023102206.jpg.7b3895151f7596f4af82f9f24d3be4f6.jpg

Note key differences with the new coin (inserted again to save some scrolling)

Zombodroid_09062023124829.jpg.0ba4e40001246e5785b75f595da4c642.jpg

- The Sa sits directly in the field above the knob atop the crown, not in a circle or atop a Crescent 

- The diadem and crown are much more realistic, and this clearly demonstrates how the prototypical "bent crown" found on (almost) all coins in Track 2 came about 

- The Crescent from Peroz's third crown is present, but unlike all other Track 2 coins, it was not yet conflated with the Pahlavi legend to create a lotus/hook shape

- The reverse legends are not yet totally degraded to three horizontal strokes.

- The obverse ribbons are much closer to their original shape than on any other Track 2 coin.

I tend to jinx myself when assigning superlatives to coins like these, but after checking Maheshwari (and I owe you folks a snap of the relevant page) this particular coin seems to be the most primitive Track 2 coin ever found!

Anyway, thanks for entertaining my rant! I do owe you all a proper overview of Indo Sassanian coinage, but life has been hectic and I haven't had the good 3-4 hours I'd need to properly assemble the pictures and write-ups, plus there's always a coin or two like this one that has me all like 

download(16).jpeg.0863642f141ba4e8d77d293967f90ff5.jpeg

  • Like 8
Posted

For my classification scheme, I use Track.Series.Type.Variety

Track - An overall evolutionary path coming from the official coins of Peroz and ending whenever people stopped making subsequent copies. Tracks span multiple centuries and contain numerous series that all share a common ancestor and often a single theme throughout. All tracks are believed to start close to the inception of Indo Sassanian coinage, e.g. probably less than a century after the end of Peroz's reign in 484.

Official coin

ZomboDroid19012022114624.jpg.f712ac9c335673214d69b377e3215536.jpg

I'm toying with the idea of a Track 0 for one-off, very early imitations of Peroz that happen to have been made in India (Persian and central Asian imitations exist and are outside of the scope of my study)

ZomboDroid22092021113145.jpg.344a23654f306049c1f361a976699879.jpg

Track 1 starts about here around the year 500-550

Zombodroid_09062023124908.jpg.4cbce6c4977b3f64ddb8982793825a04.jpg

And ends here, around the year 1350

imgonline-com-ua-twotoone-EGEOoCel2q.jpg.6eabf5cf173d4e59505801a74da9695c.jpg

Track 2 starts here probably not long after 500

Zombodroid_09062023124829.jpg.693118ac0e8733c83d702707bd65a473.jpg

And ends here; around the year 900?

ZomboDroid20042021173802.jpg.9416503753baece79cf7a6be7b6d7a79.jpg

Track 3 branches off of early Track 2 when Sa is replaced by Sri and Ma is placed before the bust, maybe around 550-625?

ZomboDroid22042022122014.jpg.c24b42db681d0abc0468c40f460b5f7a.jpg

It actually ends a but later than this coin, but it dead-ends into the "Adivaraha" coinage of Pratihara king Bhoja I (836-885) which retains only elements of the fire altar and attendants on the reverse

ZomboDroid23012020122821.jpg.c80689ecffef2bc06757903ada222c54.jpg

 

Series - A large grouping of types that would look similar to an outside observer. They usually span at least a century and can contain just a few types, or up to about a dozen.

Series 1.3 has been one of my favorite both stylistically and for the challenges in arranging them, and all are relatively small early Gadhaiya coins that bear a bust with a distinctive tall head

imgonline-com-ua-twotoone-7Nn0ZZlJ8BEsfAd.jpg.77221f01bc8c516ceeffbd9813672bd9.jpgZomboDroid01062020124223.jpg.582509d1dce61dd5e73162111352b1be.jpgZomboDroid05112021110127.jpg.3e3b0855e01e3fe64c876462655fcf23.jpgZomboDroid22042022121838.jpg.7ac6831b852b490b6d1d149ecf0cb3b0.jpgZomboDroid23032021143504.jpg.16d99e2b5860679e1192d965e3a78b52.jpg

 

Types are all generally very similar, probably made within the span of a few years up to a few decades, and certainly from the same issuing authority. They may contain some minor or moderate stylistic variances based on the engraver

Type 1.3.1 all share a stylish, boomerang-shaped head with a long, pointed nose and a very large eye orbit, although the style varies quite a bit

imgonline-com-ua-twotoone-7Nn0ZZlJ8BEsfAd.jpg.77221f01bc8c516ceeffbd9813672bd9.jpgZomboDroid04052022175616.jpg.94edfa5bd12b8ebea29ed959a610dc53.jpgZombodroid_31012023014353.jpg.040f051ded89f485a98ef9601f883587.jpgZomboDroid04052022171812.jpg.4e13a6247c8d3066ff9f65a2e1d88bb0.jpgZomboDroid25052021112812.jpg.ac9ea768779d319c97a8c48161e821af.jpg

I don't use varieties within every type, but they can be helpful to split a type up by important features, e.g. 1.3.1.1 has the archaic type flame that terminates in an extra dot, a holdover from the end of series 1.2

ZomboDroid04052022175616.jpg.94edfa5bd12b8ebea29ed959a610dc53.jpg

1.3.1.2 transforms the dot into a vertical line - important because as the only type that has both styles, we can confidently place this at the beginning of series 1.3

ZomboDroid25052021112812.jpg.ac9ea768779d319c97a8c48161e821af.jpg

Unfortunately, there aren't nearly enough anchors to tie these types to historical events or people, so the actual dates and places are more guesswork, so I focus on the evolution of the designs themselves, hoping that if I can arrange them in the "correct" order, at some point a discovery can be made that lets everything else fall into place!

  • Like 4

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...