Jump to content

ValiantKnight

Member
  • Posts

    223
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ValiantKnight

  1. 10 minutes ago, TheTrachyEnjoyer said:

    I don’t mean to be harbinger of bad news but that isn’t authentic. It looks to be a cast fake of a honorius siliqua 😟. Sorry 

    If it were me I would want to know and return it.

    Any chance you could provide details/insight on why you believe this? The red encrustation looks natural and the surface condition looks typical for wear. And the obverse and reverse being misaligned, couldn’t just that be a result of the poor quality control of these late, unofficial siliquae? I could not find any known fakes for this type.

    • Like 1
  2. I was very fortunate to have acquired a coin of this rare, short-lived, and interesting type for my collection. This was among the first coins struck by the Visigoths, and a product of the turbulent early fifth century, soon after their sack of Rome in 410. After the sack and the death of their king Alaric, the Visigoths went on to continue to ravage Italy and southern Gaul. During their time in Gaul in 414 AD, the Visigoths under King Ataulf propped up Priscus Attalus as Roman emperor for the second time against Emperor Honorius. Successful campaigning against the tribe by Honorius's general Constantius III pushed the Visigoths to abandon Attalus in 415, who was later captured by Honorius-aligned Roman forces. Also in 415, the Visigoths were brought to the negotiating table and signed a peace treaty with Honorius; subsequently, the tribe fought as foederati for the Romans against other Germanic tribes that were occupying parts of the Western Roman Empire. In 418, as a result of their service, Honorius granted them their own territory in Aquitania (in later years, the Visigoths would also extended their control to Hispania).

    During Attalus's second usurpation, siliquae were minted in his name by the Visigoths in Gaul, the mint city possibly being Narbonne (which was taken by the Visigoths in 413). Along with the Attalus siliquae, there are those that were stuck bearing Honorius's name and effigy; these carried the mintmark PSRV indicating Ravenna (however, the Visigoths never controlled Ravenna and this appropriation of a Ravenna mintmark could be seen as an attempt to make the coins more accepted). The Attalus siliquae have the reverse legend ending in "AVGG" and "AVGGG" while the Honorius coins were typically only stuck with the latter (interestingly enough on my coin it has "ACGG"; or possibly the C is a deformed V). It is not know with full certainty if these Honorius siliquae were struck before, during, or after the second usurpation and subsequent abandonment of Attalus, but according to J.P.C. Kent in his 1989 address to the Royal Numismatic Society, it is most likely that they were made after the 418 settlement treaty, with an ending date of 423 for this issue (although the earlier date of 415 is likely as well).

    In the name of Honorius, Visigoths in Gaul
    AR siliqua
    Obv: D N HONORI-VS P F AVG, pearl-diademed, draped bust right
    Rev: VICTOR-IA ACGG, Roma seated left on cuirass, holding Victory on globe and spear
    Mint: Narbonne (or another mint in Gaul)   
    Mintmark: PSRV
    Date: 415/418 to 423 AD
    Ref: RIC X 3703 var.

    1.1 grams, 11 mm wide

    VKhonoriusvisigoths.thumb.jpg.7035f0c81e8a43db19486927369987b6.jpg

    Western Roman Empire at the end of 418 AD:

    2047005389_MapaImperioOccidentalao418wikipedia.thumb.png.480f7356b8e384b3d3f74a965d37b477.png

    Sources for information and map:

    CNG (https://www.cngcoins.com/Coin.aspx?CoinID=163273)

    Wikipedia

    Please post your coins of Honorius, siliquae, the Visigoths, any/or anything else relevant!

    • Like 8
  3. As some may remember, Ptolemaic coinage is one of my main collecting areas. In the future, I will hopefully expand full-time to collecting Roman Alexandrian/Egyptian provincial coins as well. But I knew that I wanted to acquire a coin depicting the famed Lighthouse (Pharos) of Alexandria as soon as I could. This example popped up in one of my email notifications, being offered in an upcoming auction. Worn, but a clear Pharos, on a problem-free coin. I made it my priority to win, but considering the popularity of this type, I was not completely confident I would win it. When the live bidding was two coins away from my coin, I realized I had been automatically logged out of my account on the auction website! Oh no! Fortunately, my phone’s auto-fill password feature came to the rescue! I then placed my bid. In those tense few moments I was expecting to be outbid and subsequently dragged into a bidding war. But no one else decided to jump into the fray, and I walked away as the guy that won a lighthouse.

    Hadrian, Roman Empire
    AE drachm
    Obv: [AVT KAIC TΡAIAN AΔΡIANOC CEB], laureate head right, slight drapery on left shoulder
    Rev: Isis Pharia sailing right, holding sistrum, the Pharos Lighthouse to right with three figures on its summit. L-I-[H] across fields
    Mint: Alexandria
    Date: 133-134 AD
    Ref: Milne 1414; RPC 5895; Dattari 1767
    (coin information from Wildwinds)

    VKhadrian.jpg


    History and description:

    pharosofalexandriaegyptianstreets.jpeg


    The Pharos (lighthouse) of Alexandria, one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World, was constructed between the years 284-246 BC, begun during the reign of Ptolemy I Soter (one of Alexander the Great’s generals) and completed under his son Ptolemy II Philadelphus, who ruled over the Greek kingdom of Ptolemaic Egypt. It acquired its name from the island that it was originally built on, Pharos, which was later connected to the coast by a causeway. Pharos eventually became the general term for lighthouse in Greek, Spanish (faro), and in the other Romance languages. The approximately 330-foot structure (one of the tallest man-made structures in the world before the modern era), made from granite and limestone blocks and built in three stages, took 12 years to construct, and according to Pliny the Elder, cost 800 silver talents (a talent is around 60 lbs of silver). Within the rectangular base was a ramp wide enough for two horsemen. At the highest portion was a furnace that produced a flame at night, while a mirror reflected the sun’s light during the day. Each of the four corners of the rectangular base stood a statue of Triton, and at the very top of the Pharos was a statue of either Zeus, Poseidon, or Ptolemy I imagined as the sun god Helios. According to the historian Josephus, the light from the Pharos could be seen from 34 miles away. It was not the first lighthouse ever but most likely the first built on such a grand scale, and had the added function of indicating hazardous shallow or rocky waters in Alexandria’s harbor.

    pharoscutawaypinterest.jpeg

    Its supposed architect was Sostratus of Cnidus, who dedicated the Pharos to the “Divine Saviors” or the “Savior Gods; the identities of these deities is not known for certain but it is possible that Sostratus was referring to those deities that protected sailors, preeminent among them being Zeus. There is also a story regarding Sostratus, likely fictional, that he “wrote his name on the masonry inside, covered it with gypsum, and having hidden it inscribed the name of the reigning king” (How to Write History, LXII), so that when the letters of Ptolemy’s name would fall away, Sostratus’s own name would be visible.

    Posidippus, a poet at the court of Ptolemy, composed an epigram for the inauguration of the Pharos:

    "The Greeks' saviour god—O mighty Proteus—shines from Pharos thanks to Sostratus of Cnidos, son of Dexiphanes. For Egypt has no cliffs or mountains as the islands do but a breakwater, level with the ground, welcomes her ships. And so this tower cutting through the breadth and depth of heaven beacons to the farthest distances by day, and all night long the sailors borne on the waves will see the great flame blazing from its top—nor miss his aim: though he run to the Bull's Horn, he'll find Zeus the Saviour, sailing, Proteus, by this beam" (Milan Papyrus, CXV; cf. Callamachus, "I beseech thee by Zeus, the watcher of the harbour," Greek Anthology, XIII.10).

    Plan_of_AlexandriaWikipedia.png

    Eventually, the Greco-Roman period would pass for Alexandria and the rest of Egypt, when the country was conquered by the Muslim Arabs in the 7th century AD. Arab travelers and historians throughout the medieval era give accounts and provide many of the extant descriptions of the Pharos. Al-Masudi, the “Herodotos of the Arabs” who lived in the 10th century, recounts a legend in which Byzantine trickery during the 8th century resulted in the Umayyad caliph destroying a portion of the Pharos in a vain search for secret treasure. Earthquakes over the medieval period would gradually undermine and break apart the Pharos, but repairs and additions would be made from time-to-time, including an Islamic-style dome at the top replacing the Greek statue that fell after an earthquake in 956 AD, as well as a mosque in later centuries. The Pharos may have also influenced Arab minaret design and construction (a minaret is a tower adjacent to mosques from where the adhan, the Islamic call to prayer, is issued from). The 12th century geographer and traveller Ibn Jubayr reported about the Pharos after his 1183 trip to Alexandria (then under the rule of Saladin’s Ayyubid Sultanate):

    “One of the greatest wonders that we saw in this city was the lighthouse which Great and Glorious God had erected by the hands of those who were forced to such labour as ‘a sign to those who take warning from examining the fate of others’ [Quran: 15:75] and as a guide to voyagers, for without it they could not find the true course to Alexandria. It can be seen for more than seventy miles, and is of great antiquity. It is most strongly built in all directions and competes with the skies in height. Description of it falls short, the eyes fail to comprehend it, and words are inadequate, so vast is the spectacle.”

    alexandriaal-qesasmuslimheritage.jpg

    The 12th century Andalusian traveler, Abu Hamid Al-Gharnati, provides a description of the Pharos during his time and how it was utilized offensively against invading ships:

    “The first tier is a square built on a platform. The second is octagonal and the third is round. All are built of hewn stone. On the top was a mirror of Chinese iron of seven cubits wide (364 cm) used to watch the movement of ships on the other side of the Mediterranean. If the ships were those of enemies, then watchmen in the Lighthouse waited until they came close to Alexandria, and when the sun started to set, they moved the mirror to face the sun and directed it onto the enemy ships to burn them in the sea. In the lower part of the Lighthouse is a gate about 20 cubits above the ground level; one climbs to it through an archway ramp of hewn stone”.

    In the 10th century, Arab historians (incorrectly) attributed the construction of the Pharos to Cleopatra VII, or Daluka/Qulpatra in the original sources, possibly due to her reputation as a builder.

    lighthouse-alexandria-al-gharnatimuslimheritage.jpg

    By the 14th century, only the rectangular base and the entrance ramp remained, and the final remnant of the Pharos was razed in 1480 by the sultan Qaitbay to build a fort on the site (which still exists today), using original stones from the lighthouse in its construction. It was the third-longest lasting of the ancient Seven Wonders, after the Mausoleum of Halicarnassus (also lost), and the Great Pyramid of Giza (still standing).

    stagesegyptianstreets.jpg

    Virtual tour:

    I realized that, for all the hours spent playing Assassin’s Creed: Origins, which takes place towards the end of Ptolemaic Egypt, I didn’t have any good in-game screenshots of the Pharos (I may have had one or two in my gallery before switching PlayStation 4 consoles a few years back). So, for this thread, I decided to give myself a virtual tour of the Pharos, using the game’s Discovery Mode, an added feature to explore Egypt as represented in the game for the purpose of, well, discovery and learning, without having to worry about being attacked by soldiers, bandits, wild animals, etc. or otherwise dying if I played normally (in the game’s main playthrough, the base around the Pharos is guarded and I would have been attacked on sight). Of course, I am not an expert on the exact details of the structure itself, so I don’t know for sure how much of it the game’s designers got right. I imagine any inaccuracies are probably gameplay elements (to facilitate features such as parkour and allow cover from guards), re-use of existing game assets for convenience (like how many of the Greek temples in-game share the same exact statue of Zeus, Serapis, etc.), or to enhance the visuals/look of the Pharos. Props to all the people that worked on developing Origins and doing the historical research for it!

    (click any to enlarge)
    ACOriginsVK44.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK41.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK15.jpeg
     


    ACOrigins__VK37.jpeg

    (this Ptolemaic soldier somehow missed the wood pillar during practice. My character was not impressed!)
    ACOrigins__VK36.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK38.jpeg

    (the ramp inside of the Pharos)
    ACOrigins__VK13.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK49.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK 30.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK22.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK24.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK21.jpeg

    ACOrigins__VK35.jpeg

    Sources for information and images (excluding coin photos and game screenshots):

    Wildwinds.com

    Wikipedia.org

    https://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/greece/paganism/pharos.html

    https://muslimheritage.com/lighthouse-of-alexandria/

    https://www.worldhistory.org/Lighthouse_of_Alexandria/

    Please feel free to share any coins depicting lighthouses, Hadrian, or anything else relevant to the thread!
    • Like 13
  4. Mine is a reverse depicting the monogram of King Odoacer (also spelled Odovacar), the foederati leader that deposed Romulus Augustus in 476 AD and put an end to the Roman Empire in the West. He was my white whale ruler/coin and it is my favorite coin in my collection. The decline and fall of Rome is my favorite Roman historical era and so a collecting focus of mine.

     

    Odoacer, Kingdom of Italy
    AE nummus
    Obv: OD[O-VAC], bare-headed, draped bust right
    Rev: Odoacer's monogram (letters ODOVA: “Odovacar”) within wreath
    Mint: Ravenna
    Date: 476-493 AD
    Ref: RIC X 3502

    [IMG]

    • Like 16
  5. 3 hours ago, David Atherton said:

    Hershey approves of this thread!

    On another note, are you able to post the content of your lighthouse coin thread here? I did a similar one a year or so ago, but yours is magnificent.

    Nice to see you here!

    Appreciate the warm welcome David and the kind words about my Pharos coin. I will post my Pharos thread in this forum soon; I had decided against it initially because I figured most here probably already saw it, but later I realized why my CT thread hasn’t gotten much traction is probably precisely because most CT ancients members are here now! I hope you post your example in this forum as well!

    • Like 2
  6. I took in a stray in May of last year, my first cat, and he's been a very wonderful part of my life ever since. Here's Mr. Kitty!

    VKKitty1.jpg.36520b3f0e8937ae014b38594834f08c.jpg

     

    VKKitty3.thumb.jpg.be4f1f2322935da67db81726001af669.jpg

    VKKitty2.jpg.ea5225492bf3febd61c91f93e11b6a11.jpg

     

    And here's a former coin of mine with a lion (I currently have a couple other lion coins but I need to photograph them):

    Miletos, Ionia
    AR twelfth-stater
    Obv: Forepart of lion left, head turned
    Rev: Floral, star, or sun pattern in incuse square
    Mint: Miletos
    Date: 525-494 BC
    Ref: SNG Cop 952

    miletos.thumb.jpg.efcd9af8e69f30da5e04ed06dc0e0189.jpg

     

    • Like 17
    • Heart Eyes 2
  7. Some of you already saw it but here it is again. This is so going to be in my Top 10 for 2022! Here's my CT thread on it: https://www.cointalk.com/threads/lighthouse-of-alexandria-coin-history-and-a-virtual-journey.396808/

    Hadrian, Roman Empire
    AE drachm
    Obv: [AVT KAIC TΡAIAN AΔΡIANOC CEB], laureate head right, slight drapery on left shoulder
    Rev: Isis Pharia sailing right, holding sistrum, the Pharos Lighthouse to right with three figures on its summit. L-I-[H] across fields
    Mint: Alexandria
    Date: 133-134 AD
    Ref: Milne 1414; RPC 5895; Dattari 1767
    (coin information from Wildwinds)

    VKhadrian.jpg

    • Like 26
    • Heart Eyes 1
×
×
  • Create New...