Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 8, 2024 · Member Posted October 8, 2024 (edited) While looking for a Carthaginian Gold Stater, I came across this coin: At first glance, I saw nothing that bothered me about the coin, but then I zoomed in and saw that there is something strange in the upper-left edge of this coin, so can somebody here please tell me what that strange little thing is? Edited October 8, 2024 by Croatian Coin Collector Quote
Benefactor DonnaML Posted October 8, 2024 · Benefactor Benefactor Posted October 8, 2024 2 hours ago, Croatian Coin Collector said: While looking for a Carthaginian Gold Stater, I came across this coin: At first glance, I saw nothing that bothered me about the coin, but then I zoomed in and saw that there is something strange in the upper-left edge of this coin, so can somebody here please tell me what that strange little thing is? It would help if you put a dot or arrow next to whatever you're asking about. 1 Quote
Ryro Posted October 8, 2024 · Supporter Posted October 8, 2024 A speck of click bate? Jk, seriously though, what are you talking about? 1 1 Quote
Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 8, 2024 · Member Author Posted October 8, 2024 25 minutes ago, DonnaML said: It would help if you put a dot or arrow next to whatever you're asking about. 1 Quote
El Cazador Posted October 8, 2024 · Member Posted October 8, 2024 3 hours ago, Croatian Coin Collector said: While looking for a Carthaginian Gold Stater, I came across this coin: At first glance, I saw nothing that bothered me about the coin, but then I zoomed in and saw that there is something strange in the upper-left edge of this coin, so can somebody here please tell me what that strange little thing is? Fine style, but poor surfaces Quote
Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 8, 2024 · Member Author Posted October 8, 2024 7 minutes ago, El Cazador said: Fine style, but poor surfaces 1 1 Quote
Hrefn Posted October 8, 2024 · Supporter Posted October 8, 2024 NGC may grade the surfaces as 4/5, but I do not agree. Like an Impressionist painting, best appreciated from a distance. Overall, a nice coin, though. I would be happy to have it in my collection. Quote
Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 9, 2024 · Member Author Posted October 9, 2024 9 hours ago, Hrefn said: NGC may grade the surfaces as 4/5, but I do not agree. Like an Impressionist painting, best appreciated from a distance. Overall, a nice coin, though. I would be happy to have it in my collection. In my experience some coins that looked in pictures like they have or might have surface issues, had none when I actually saw them in person, and I would be willing to bet that is the case here as well, I doubt that both NGC and CNG would rate a coin with surface issues highly, but in any case, this thread isn't about that, it is about the strange thing in the upper-left edge of the coin, I haven't noticed anything like that on a coin before. 1 Quote
sand Posted October 9, 2024 · Member Posted October 9, 2024 Maybe it is a bit of dirt, from when the coin was in the ground. It's so small, that it amazes me, that you noticed it. 2 Quote
Ed Snible Posted October 9, 2024 · Member Posted October 9, 2024 More photos are needed. I don't know what the purity of Carthage staters was. I've heard Greek and Roman gold coins were about 23 karet, 95% gold. Could this be a bit of bronze or base metal that didn't fully mix with the gold, that corroded? 1 1 Quote
Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 9, 2024 · Member Author Posted October 9, 2024 8 minutes ago, Ed Snible said: More photos are needed. I don't know what the purity of Carthage staters was. I've heard Greek and Roman gold coins were about 23 karet, 95% gold. Could this be a bit of bronze or base metal that didn't fully mix with the gold, that corroded? Unfortunately, I don't own the coin, so I can't take any pictures, and the best picture I could find online is the NGC one I posted in the opening post. Quote
Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 9, 2024 · Member Author Posted October 9, 2024 44 minutes ago, sand said: Maybe it is a bit of dirt, from when the coin was in the ground. It's so small, that it amazes me, that you noticed it. I am one of those people who notice when something is out of place, and it took me about a second after zooming in to notice that there was something weird in the upper-left edge of this coin. Quote
Croatian Coin Collector Posted October 11, 2024 · Member Author Posted October 11, 2024 (edited) I have decided that I am not going to bid on it, if somebody else wants to bid on it, you can do so here: https://www.biddr.com/auctions/gadoury/browse?a=4979&l=6049999 Edited October 11, 2024 by Croatian Coin Collector 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.